Is Harry Potter of the Devil?

Harry Potter

Harry PotterI recently finished reading the entire Harry Potter series. It took me some time to get through them as I had some breaks. It began as reading to my sons at bedtime but I eventually read the rest of the series for my own enjoyment.

I have had some Christians surprised that I would read Harry Potter. I appreciate people’s concern and I am happy to explain my appreciation for the Harry Potter series.

Why I Like Harry Potter

At its foundation, the Harry Potter books are about the battle between good and evil. It deals with the evil nature of Tom Riddle, a young wizard who eventually becomes the most powerful dark wizard, Voldemort. Voldemort killed Harry’s parents and attempted to kill Harry. Harry survived only because of the power of love. Circumstances lead to a final battle between good and evil. Along the way is a story of friendship and sacrifice.

Do the Harry Potter Books Indoctrinate Children in Sorcery and Satanism?

Harry PotterI have no reason to believe any children have gone from reading Harry Potter books to joining a witch’s coven or a satanic cult. Do some children wish they had a magic wand or a flying broomstick? Such imagination has been a part of childhood for as long as fairy tales have been around.

The truth is that world created by J.K. Rowling has nothing to do with the religion of Wicca. While Wiccans believe in magic, I doubt you can find one who shoots laser beams out of magic wands. What about Satanism? Wicca and Satanism are not the same religion. Wiccans don’t believe in Satan much less worship him. I really do not see how anyone could make the jump from reading Harry Potter to worshipping Satan (which most Satanists don’t do any way).

Doesn’t the Bible Prohibit Sorcery?

The Bible does indeed command against sorcery. The question is, what is the nature of sorcery that the Bible addresses? This understanding of magic and sorcery seems to be calling upon spiritual beings (gods or demons) to manipulate their power for dark purposes. The Bible especially critical of divination which was a real problem in the ancient world.

What is the World of Harry Potter Like?

Any reader of Harry Potter will notice that there are no spiritual beings on which the wizards and witches call on. In fact the world that Rowling created was not one which people can just choose to practice magic. Magical ability is something that you are born with, not something you choose. In the Potter universe, such power is often genetic with one or both parents having magical ability. A child manifests magic as a natural ability without using spells. Those who don’t have magic are called muggles and there is no sense that they can just learn spells or call upon a demon. At times, magical parents have a child with no magical ability and they are known as squibs. Magic in the Harry Potter books is much closer to the mutant phenomenon in the X-Men more than what we find in the Bible. It should also be noted that divination is criticized in the Potter books and it is clear that Trelawney, professor of divination is a fake.

I am not suggesting that people uncomfortable with Harry Potter should start reading the books. If you think it is wrong, don’t do it. But for those who read Harry Potter along with other fantasy books with witches and wizards (e.g. books by C.S. Lewis and J.R.R. Tolkien), it is completely compatible with Christian faith. I found the final book, The Deathly Hallows, to be filled with Christian themes (and a number of biblical passages). I speak only for myself when I say I appreciated the series.


(Visited 662 times, 1 visits today)
Liked it? Take a second to support Stephen Bedard on Patreon!
Share

3 thoughts on “Is Harry Potter of the Devil?

  1. I dont believe Harry Potter along with other fantasy books with witches and wizards (e.g. books by C.S. Lewis and J.R.R. Tolkien), are compatible with Christian faith! They may well have been write by believers but hold very little value to the Christian faith. After all, Christianity is about Jesus. If you don’t mention Christ what’s the point? All that time spent entertaining once self by reading about dark forces and fantasys would of been better spent reading the bible! Just my opinion!

    1. I’m curious, if you say ” If you don’t mention Christ what’s the point?” does that mean that you think the entire Old Testament is useless?

      If your answer is, “well Christ is implied, prophesied/etc” then you’re effectively undercutting the argument you made here. After all, you don’t need to explicitly mention Christ to put forward a Christian worldview. But if you want to press the point made here, you’d have to argue that because there are no explicit mentions of Jesus Christ in the Old Testament, it is worthless. And that, I would say, would be extremely problematic.

  2. Thanks for this post, Stephen. I think you’ve hit on some great points, but I’d also point out that plenty in the books resonates–at times explicitly–with the Christian worldview. I pointed out one of the most explicit parts in my look at the last movie, here: http://jwwartick.com/2011/07/19/hp-dh-2/

    I don’t want to spoil the plot for anyone, so be warned there are plenty of spoilers at that link. To put it as spoiler-free as possible, there seems to be some parallels of Christ in the series.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *