There is a lot of discussion about Christian apologist Wesley Huff who has been accused of multiple accounts of plagiarism. Everyone is quick to have an opinion, either condemning or defending.
In the midst of all of this, I have been observing the comments on all sides. There are some things being said that are concerning. Here are five mistakes that I see people making. I am not claiming that I have gotten everything right myself.
Rejecting Because of the Source
The first claims of plagiarism came from biblical scholar Dan McClellan. McClellan is not a christian, in fact many of his videos are aimed at criticizing traditional views of the Bible. McClellan is also a Mormon.
I have seen a number of defenders of Wes rejecting the claims simply because of who they are coming from. Since McClellan has an agenda, these must be lies against a godly man.
This is called the genetic fallacy, rejecting something because of the source.
What is important is whether or not the claims are true. McClellan may have an agenda, but if what he says is true, it must be addressed. Falling into the genetic fallacy does not help the cause of Christian apologetics.
See Dangerous Fallacies Commonly Used by Christian Apologists
Assuming Motivation
If there is indeed evidence for plagiarism, as there seems to be, the next question is about motivation. What this just sloppiness as Wes claimed in his initial response? Or is it an attempt to deceive as many of his critics have claimed?
The truth is that only Wes knows. Making assumptions about his motivation is not helpful. I understand that people are venting outrage, but do it with some honesty that we do not know the full story.
Excusing Because of Success
I have seen some supporters of Wes rejecting the claims because of all of the success that Wes Huff has had. He has been on some very prominent platforms and has had the opportunity to share about Jesus to a wide audience.
Wes Huff has been received very positively, partially because of his knowledge and partially because of his winsome style. With all that he has done for the kingdom of God, should we really take these concerns seriously?
Unfortunately, this kind of thinking has been used to excuse the activity of many Christian leaders. This was used to defend Ravi Zacharias. I am not comparing what Wes did to what Zacharias did, but there is a similarity in defence.
The truth is the truth, even if the person has done some great things. Refusing to examine the evidence because of what they have done in the past is a dangerous path.
See Why Wesley Huff Made Such an Impact on the Joe Rogan Show
What Does This Mean For Us?
Many see this situation as purely about Wes Huff. It is about him but role is not just to support or criticize. It is also about learning for ourselves. What lesson do we take from this?
Wes was a rising star and was among the most respected popular Christian apologists of today, at least by evangelicals. In a matter of a few days, so much has fallen apart.
Do we think that we are immune from this? Plagiarism may not be our danger but there is always something. Any of us could find ourselves in such a fall.
Much of our vulnerability is based on assumption that things can be kept secret. But secrets always come out. How many of the most respected Christians from 15 years ago are now seen as outcasts?
Instead of putting all of our energy into judging Wes, why don’t we take Wes’s experience and use it for self-reflection? Let us consider carefully how we can protect ourselves.
Human Compassion
In all of this, many people seem to forget that Wes is a human being with feelings. Where is the empathy? Some have suggested that he is outside of empathy because of being a public figure and the nature of his ministry.
I reject that. Every human being deserves some compassion. Committing plagiarism does not put one outside of that. I am especially disappointed by the nastiness of people who identify as Christians. You can take a strong stand on plagiarism without demonizing a person.
I do not know what the future holds for Wes. I wish the best for him and his family. I take seriously the accusations of plagiarism and I agree that there needs to be accountability. But this can be done in thoughtful and compassionate ways.



McClellan is a Christian. He believes Jesus died for his sins. Even if McClellan were not a Christian, he accurately points out Huff’s plagiarism. Huff is a good Christian man who is a proven serial plagiarist. More’s the pity.