Sorting by

×
Posted in

Is the Wes Huff Controversy a Sign of the Sickness of Evangelicalism?

Is the Wes Huff Controversy a Sign of the Sickness of Evangelicalism?

I do not think there is much left to say about Wes Huff and the controversy about his plagiarism. Wes has apologized and it is up to the organizations that he is affiliated with to decide what to do next.

And yet there are those on social media who are suggesting that what has happened is really only a symptom of a larger problem. For some, this is a sign of the larger problems with Protestantism/Evangelicalism.

By the way, I know that Protestantism and Evangelicalism are not synonyms. Evangelicalism is a subset of Protestantism. I share both here because, depending on who you ask, they will give you either one of those groups as being the problem.

Many of these criticisms have come from Roman Catholics and Orthodox. I am not sure if there had been an already existing conflict between them and Wes or if it was an ongoing debate online between them and Protestants and Evangelicals.

The types of arguments include the problem that the Protestants do not have a central authority to tell individuals what they can and cannot do. Protestantism is a theological “wild west” where everyone does what they want to.

The problem with this is that this is not an issue limited to Protestants. I cannot speak about the Orthodox but there are plenty of online Roman Catholic apologists who are operating without any specific authorization from a bishop or any other authority.

And that is okay. I am not criticizing either Roman Catholics or Orthodox Christians. I am only saying that the Internet is the great democratizer. It allows people of any religion or no religion to promote their beliefs and to criticize other people’s beliefs. Protestants/Evangelicals are not the only ones involved in this.

The other criticism is that Evangelicals are especially prone to celebrity culture. Evangelicals put people like Wes Huff on pedestals and history demonstrates that many of the people we wanted as heroes were more flawed than we realized.

There is some truth to this, in that Evangelicals do embrace celebrity culture. Remember all those Christians who embraced to conversion of Russell Brand? What about Kanye West?

Having said that, I also do not think that is limited to Evangelicals. One of the moral failures that hit me the hardest was that of Jean Vanier, a Roman Catholic. There are others as well that do not fit into the Evangelical category.

However, celebrity culture is not an essential element of Evangelicalism, nor is it a sign that Evangelicalism is theologically bankrupt.

It can be a helpful warning that we should not get involved in hero worship or to place Christians on pedestals that they are likely to fall from. We can recognize the success of Christian leaders in a healthy way and not fall into unhealthy patterns.

What some people are doing is taking the unfortunate example of Wes Huff and they are weaponizing it for their own purposes. Protestants and Evangelicals do the same thing when there is fall from someone in a group they disagree with.

What happened with Wes only proves that human beings can do some bad things. It does not prove that there is a core problem with any particular group.

Liked it? Take a second to support Stephen Bedard on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!
Share

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.