What is the Difference Between a PhD and a DMin?

You may also like...

6 Responses

  1. Don says:

    To put it is a more simple way, a PhD is an **academic degree** for professors and researchers in a particular field of endeavor. Back in the day, the equivalent in theology was a ThD, and I guess you can still get this degree at some schools.

    A Doctor of Ministry degree (DMin) is a **professional degree** for clergy. Other professional degrees include the Juris Doctor (JD) for lawyers and the DDS for dentists.

    It used to be that the standard professional theological degree for pastors was the Bachelor of Divinity (BD). It was a 3-year degree and a BA was not required to earn it. Later, when a BA was required to gain entrance into a seminary, they changed the BD to a graduate degree, the Master of Divinity (MDiv), which is also a professional, not academic degree).

    To offer equality with other professionals, the Doctor of Ministry (DMin) was invented. That abbreviation is unfortunate (“demon”) for people in theology, but there you have it. Standards for getting a DMin are pretty low, the quality depending where you get it. Basically, it replaces the DD (Doctor of Divinity) which was both an earned degree at some places, but mostly an honorary degree bestowed on pastors by Christian colleges and seminaries.

    • I will say that the standards at Acadia Divinity College where I am doing my DMin are high.

      • Don says:

        I did the DMin work at San Francisco Theological Seminary after getting an MDiv from Princeton Seminary. But I did not finish the final unit due to life circumstances. But I was pleased with what they offered. It was practical as opposed to academic.

        I was a pastor at the time and the DMin suited my needs. I ended up spending my entire ministry career as a Christian journalist and the pastoral practicums would have been of little value. I got an MA from Wheaton Graduate School before Princeton, and what I learned about Communications in that program met my journalistic and publishing work needs.

        I would say that a DMin degree is not essential for ministry. Looks good on the church sign and stationery, but it is more like continuing education rather than a terminal degree in the rest of academia.

        It’s always been my opinion that when you go to a three year seminary, you should get an Doctor of Divinity at the end, not just a Master of Divinity. That would put it on par with the standard Juris Doctor (law) degree which has 3 years of post-BA studies and is the case with many other professional degrees. You can even get an MD degree in 3-4 years beyond college, though specialist studies and hospital internships add to the core time.

        Unfortunately, theological education is hindered by history. The time it takes, the training people get, and the degrees they earn are largely mandated by an old, outdated methodology.

      • John says:

        I think it’s a stretch to suggest that “standards for getting a DMin are pretty low.” ATS accredited programs are pretty rigorous.

        • While some DMin programs have bad reputations, the program I am in at Acadia Divinity College has high standards.

        • Don says:

          In fairness, I did not say “standards for getting a DMin are pretty low.” I said: “Standards for getting a DMin are pretty low, the quality depending where you get it.” Big difference!

          While there may be concerns with ATS, many schools offering the DMin degree are not associated with ATS at all. I notice that Acadia Divinity College is a member of that professional theological accrediting agency. 269 other theological schools also have their accreditation.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *